Press "Enter" to skip to content

World

How Americans Vote

In just a few days, Greece will be holding three elections, European and local, and all the usual clichés about “election fever” are making their inevitable appearance. Among the many things that unfortunately trivialise both the process and its significance — such as the sheer number of candidates and the political quality they represent — a conversation a few days ago with a lawyer friend, soon to serve as an electoral representative, raised some interesting questions concerning the electoral process itself and its modernisation. Eventually, our discussion turned to how elections are conducted on the other side of the Atlantic, and I promised to provide a summary in this article. Along with that promise came another: anyone reading it would end up crying… with laughter.

Elections in the United States could best be described as a tragicomedy, at least by the standards of what we know from European democracies. In a rather peculiar way, as happens with so many things in American society, they seem to work. But between “seeming” to work and actually guaranteeing the democratic legitimacy of such a process — and consequently of the election of the country’s leaders — there may be a rather small… abyss.

Since elections in the United States are held for all sorts of governing bodies, so many that even the people voting for them barely know what they are, this article will focus on a few basic aspects of the election of the person occupying one of the most important, if not the most powerful, political offices on the planet: the President.

American presidential elections are often said to produce the “ruler of the planet”, and although many people make the wonderfully original joke involving a certain well-known canine crooner, the electoral process itself may actually be less serious than what goes on in the entertainment venues where that humble microphone-wielding performer appears.

We will completely bypass the process of selecting presidential candidates, since this is not a procedure established by the laws of the state (which state, exactly?), but merely a tradition maintained by the political parties. Instead, we will concentrate on what happens once the candidates have been announced, something expected to take place in the summer of 2020 for the next presidential election, whose campaign has already been under way… since last year.

Let us start with the basics. The election of the President is governed by the Constitution of the United States. Which article? None. The United States has made sure not to have a complete Constitution, but whenever something new was needed, they simply drafted an amendment and shoved it in. Thus, various amendments to the Constitution determine, at the federal level, how the President is elected. One could begin with this point and then analyse how we get there, but that would destroy the chronological continuity of the process, turning what is supposed to be a description of a farce into something even more complicated than a research paper in theoretical mathematics.

So, let us imagine that it is July, a few months before the presidential election, which takes place towards the end of the year (we will explain exactly when later). You leave your house to go to the supermarket for a few essentials. On your way, you are approached by some people carrying sheets of paper that passers-by are signing. You assume they are collecting signatures for some worthy cause, perhaps protecting the environment or replacing the streetlights. But you are wrong! This is the procedure through which you register… to vote!

In order to cast a ballot on Election Day — or, more precisely, to belong to the electorate whose votes determine the popular vote — you must first register on the electoral rolls. You are not automatically included. Registration is something you have to do yourself. You can register at a political party’s local office, but you can also register out on the street, where volunteers from the various parties are collecting signatures! By this point, one can already appreciate that student elections in a university department with a few dozen students are conducted with greater seriousness.

Having registered on a humble but useful piece of paper that will be used to compile the electoral roll, while on your way to buy some equally humble but useful toilet paper, you spend the next few months watching television until your brain turns into a vegetable and the day finally comes when you can vote. That day will be a Tuesday in November, specifically the Tuesday falling between the 2nd and the 8th day of the eleventh month of the year.

In August, however, you go on a trip to another state. The heat is unbearable. You leave your hotel room and decide to get yourself an ice cream. But on your way to enjoy this frozen delight, your blood runs cold when you realise that here, too, people on the street are asking you to register to vote. It does not matter whether you have already registered somewhere else. You can sign up here as well. Perhaps, through some magical mechanism, a solution will eventually be found. Or perhaps, through another equally mysterious mechanism, nobody will ever find out whether it was.

Generally speaking, anyone can register whoever they like on the electoral rolls, wherever they like. But if you have not registered, you cannot vote. Make sure you remember that!

The months go by, and eventually the time comes to cast your ballot. For some reason, FOX News has turned your brain into such a hopeless mess that you decide to stage a revolution and vote for Mickey Mouse. And, for some reason, Mickey Mouse is not merely a mouse-shaped Disney character, but also a 35-year-old man living in Wyoming, born after his parents got married during their first trip to Las Vegas after finishing school.

And so, you arrive at the polling station. You have no idea whether it will be crowded or almost empty. If you are white, you will probably be finished in no time, because relatively few people are assigned to your polling station. If you belong to another racial group, however, you will probably have to spend the entire day waiting under the scorching sun, in the pouring rain or in the snow, depending on which state you happen to live in.

Everyone has the right to vote, regardless of race, but nobody says that exercising this right has to be equally easy for everyone, do they?

Eventually, it is time to verify your identity against the electoral register. Naturally, you do not have your identity card with you, for the simple reason that there is no national identity card in the United States. A driving licence usually serves that purpose. But what happens if you do not have a driving licence? After all, nobody is legally obliged to have one, or a passport for that matter. In other words, nobody is required to possess any form of identification.

Provided, of course, that they are not an immigrant. Immigrants must carry approximately 250,000 documents, both electronic and physical, at all times.

But you need not worry about any of this. Jessica and Todd are there as two witnesses who can confirm that they know you, just as they know practically anyone else who needs them, and you can vote normally. As long as nobody else turns up to claim that they are you, there is absolutely no problem.

Now, if you decide to vote under your grandmother’s name, knowing perfectly well that she will not be voting, even though she somehow ended up on the electoral roll, well, perhaps such things do happen. But they are hardly the sort of things that ought to happen in a society as angelically perfect as that of a global superpower.

Having finally reached the technologically hyper-advanced post-voting-booth contraption, you get your hands on the ballot paper. Yes, there is only one. There are not several, probably for environmental reasons.

Unfortunately, Mickey Mouse is nowhere to be found on it. Never mind. After all, quite a few people who are actually running for office do not appear on the ballot either. Some committee has decided, on the basis of electoral predictions, whose names should appear and in what order, or at least as many as can fit on the paper.

So, you can take another piece of paper and vote for Mickey Mouse instead of choosing one of the two candidates prominently displayed at the top of the ballot: John Morgan and Mark Heizenberg.

Most people, however, vote for either Morgan or Heizenberg. At least, that is what they think they are doing.

But the President is not elected by the people. The people vote for electors. These electors, whose names do not appear on the ballot and for whom you do not explicitly vote, are the individuals pledged to support the presidential candidate of your choice, or at least that is what they have declared.

However, although it rarely happens, in 26 of the 50 states they can change their minds on the day the Electoral College votes, without facing any legal consequences whatsoever. For the sake of simplicity, we will assume that the electors are “honest” and that we will not end up with a scenario in which you vote for Morgan and Heizenberg wins.

But which electors will actually be elected?

Ah! That is not quite so straightforward.

Most states award all their electors to whichever candidate receives the highest number of votes. Thus, a candidate could win 51% of the vote in one state and 0% in another state with an identical population, and despite receiving only 25.5% of the combined popular vote, end up with exactly the same number of electors as an opponent who received 74.5%.

Wonderful, isn’t it?

Well, it gets even better.

Apart from this system, there are also two states which, instead of awarding all their electors to the overall winner, give some to the winner of the statewide vote and the rest to the winner of each electoral district.

In short, the election of electors produces a magical number generated by some insane algorithm after all the votes have been collected. You can be far more certain which university department you will be admitted to after submitting your preferences in the Greek national university entrance examinations than you can be about how many electors each presidential candidate will secure on the basis of the votes ostensibly cast in their favour through this supposed expression of the popular will.

Through this magical process, Morgan receives 52% of the vote and Heizenberg 48%. Mickey Mouse, meanwhile, has received your vote, and the electors assemble in December to elect the President.

By an equally “magical” process, everyone already knows that Heizenberg is the President-elect, since he has secured more electors. The procedure, although constitutionally significant, is effectively a formality, since the electors “honestly” perform their duty and Heizenberg is declared the next President of the United States, with the inauguration taking place towards the end of January the following year.

So, what did you think of all that?

If you did not particularly enjoy it, do not worry. Within a year and a half, the process of selecting candidates for the next election will already have begun, so there is no need to waste time wondering what went wrong. Perhaps the next lottery will produce the candidate the people actually voted for, or at least the one most people would have preferred to see elected.

Among other things, throughout this entire process, you have also voted for a whole series of additional offices, mostly at the local level, which somehow never received much attention. Yet, by some mysterious means, certain individuals have acquired positions of power.

And, lo and behold, among them is Mickey Mouse himself, who now holds an administrative position in the county where he lives, in exotic Wyoming.

© Aegletes Coelispex 2026